You guys were pretty quick to attack the critic, but he is quite right on alot of it. Perhaps too shouty, but still.
For instance go from this page to try and find documentation on module building, after many many links, you get into the circular world of the wiki ... with no useful documentation.
Also try looking for info about putting a CSS sheet in just one module, not the whole theme, cannot find anything on that and been searching for months.
The point about un maintained modules is also true, why are they listed if they are not maintained?
In answer to the "so you wont be using XOOPS then" response, i personally have to use it here at work, but it is already decided that we are moving away (not my personal decision) and that is purely down to the difficulty in finding the documentation - My boss cannot find sufficient documentation to make him happy they can cope if i leave. Documentation is scattered so far and wide the only document we do use here is the Smarty documentation.
The forum is much improved but the code of XOOPS is not perfect and the project is not very well managed, sorry but it is true.
If these criticisms are hard to hear, then why have a "XOOPS.org feedback & suggestions " section on the forum.
While we are at it, is there a way to add CSS to only one module (since all modules include the same header)?